|
I-35W BRIDGE
COLLAPSE SERVES AS A WARNING
By
Marty Baker, Editor
Much news time in recent months has
been devoted to the collapse of the I-35W bridge, with
riveting stories on the Internet and television and in many
newspapers and magazines. Government leaders in charge of
allocating funding and taxpayers footing the bills need to
sit up and take notice of the world’s deteriorating
infrastructure. Meanwhile, transportation departments,
engineers, and indeed welders need to be ready when the
funding is released to repair and replace deteriorating
bridges, tunnels, and pipelines.
The Minnesota bridge collapse was one
of the more tragic and recent in our memories, but in
reality, it is not an isolated event. It is just one in a
lengthy list of bridges that have collapsed for various
reasons to include:
- July 2007 – A
highway overpass under construction in Oroville,
California collapsed
- April 2007 – A
section of freeway off the San Francisco-Oakland Bay
Bridge collapsed
- September 2006 – A
bridge collapsed in Quebec, Canada
- November 2005 – A
bridge in southern Spain collapsed
- May 2002 – A bridge
spanning the Arkansas River in Webbers Falls, Oklahoma
collapsed.
- August 2002 – Two
bridges in Central China collapsed
And the list goes on.
According to Greg Gordon, “U.S.
Saw Need in 1998 to Fix Nation’s Bridges,” [http://www.twincities.com]
there are nearly 600,000 federally funded bridges and 79,523
of them are classified as functionally obsolete,
meaning that they need to be replaced. While not limited
to, much focus has been placed on the steel deck truss
bridges that use a non-redundant design structure… meaning
that if a single part failed, the whole structure could
collapse. Such was the case with the Silver Bridge in Ohio
that failed the year of its completion in 1967 because of
the failure of a single chain link. Since that time,
fundamental reform of bridge design and safety has
occurred. However, many of our bridges pre-date the 1960s
and the Federal Highway Administration indicates that there
are 756 steel deck truss bridges in the U.S. that carry a
design of the I-35W bridge.
In the U.S., bridges are inspected at
least annually and inspectors rank bridges by visual
inspection of the steel and concrete used in decks, piers,
joints, corrosion, and other criteria. Problems can
include, but are not limited to, corroding steel, cracked
concrete, and fatigue cracking.
The
American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) assembled a
panel of 24 of the nation’s leading civil engineers who
conducted an extensive study and survey to develop the
Report Card For America’s Infrastructure [http://www.asce.org/reportcard/2005/index.cfm].
Using grading categories A through F and I for incomplete,
the highest grade given to any infrastructure was a C
(mediocre). For bridges, they estimate that it will cost
$9.4 billion a year for twenty years to eliminate all bridge
deficiencies. And bridges were just one type of structure
in those listed. Most all of those deficient structures in
the listing will require welding for reconstruction.
Government entities must be cautious of
hiring the contractors with the “lowest and best” bid in
view of the fact that less-than-reputable firms may be
tempted to bid low to get the work and then hire unqualified
employees at low rates to perform the construction. Safety
is compromised when people who do not possess valid welding
certifications are hired to perform the construction.
Contractors must be ready with
qualified workers to bid on the projects and Hobart
Institute stands ready to offer training, certification and
qualification to prepare welders for the work, whether it be
for bridges, dams, locks, rail, schools, aviation, energy,
or other applications. As an
American Welding Society (AWS) accredited test facility,
Hobart Institute offers individuals an opportunity to
perform welding skill tests to various codes and
specifications that outline the qualifications for the
welders and provide a guide and requirements for engineers
and contractors. One of those is the AWS D1.5 Bridge
Welding Code. AWS also publishes D1.1 for structural
welding of steel, D1.2 for structural welding of aluminum,
and others to set forth standards for welding. While these
codes are recognized nationwide, each state may apply the
code according to their own guidelines or state statutes.
In the United States, it is easy to
take our infrastructure for granted and look the other way.
Warnings have been issued by Stephen Flynn [The
Edge of Disaster: Rebuilding a Resilient Nation, 2007]
and by the ASCE and others. We expect that what our parents
and grandparents built will last forever. It is time to
redirect our attention on how we can make things better and
begin the preservation work to leave the world a better
place for our children and grandchildren.
|